For anyone visiting the Sierra Nevada Mountains and looking for a hearty bite, the Old New York Deli in Mammoth Lakes offers a delightful blend of East Coast deli tradition with a warm California twist. Nestled in the heart of this scenic mountain town, the deli has become a popular destination for locals and tourists alike. With its generous portions, freshly baked bagels, and friendly service, it brings a taste of New York to the slopes of Mammoth. Whether you’re starting your day with a hot breakfast or grabbing lunch before an afternoon hike, this deli captures the essence of comfort food served fast and fresh.
History and Location
Old New York Deli & Bakery Co. has roots that go back to a passion for authentic New York-style deli cuisine. Opened in Mammoth Lakes, California, the establishment quickly became known not only for its delicious bagels and sandwiches but also for the cozy, inviting atmosphere. It’s located conveniently in the Village at Mammoth, making it easy to find for visitors who are out enjoying the shops, events, or heading to the gondola lift during ski season.
Why It’s Loved by Locals and Tourists
One of the reasons Old New York Deli stands out is its commitment to quality. Everything is made fresh, from the soft, chewy bagels to the rich cream cheeses and robust coffee. It’s a rare gem in a mountain town that often sees transient food options. The deli offers something more permanent: a reliable, delicious experience that keeps people coming back year after year.
Signature Menu Items
The menu at Old New York Deli Mammoth is both extensive and satisfying. Breakfast is served all day, which is a huge plus for those who hit the slopes early or sleep in after a long day of snowboarding or hiking.
Popular Breakfast Options
- Bagel Sandwiches– A favorite among regulars, especially when loaded with egg, bacon, sausage, or avocado.
- Fresh Baked Bagels– Made daily in a variety of flavors including plain, everything, sesame, and cinnamon raisin.
- Omelets and Scrambles– Customizable with a wide range of fillings, from veggies to meats and cheeses.
Lunch Favorites
- Reuben Sandwich– Made with lean corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing on rye bread.
- Turkey Avocado Club– A stacked sandwich packed with fresh ingredients and hearty flavor.
- Classic BLT– Crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and tomato served on toasted sourdough or the bread of your choice.
Pastries and Sweets
Beyond savory dishes, the deli also features a rotating selection of muffins, croissants, brownies, and cookies. The bakery side of the operation ensures that everything is fresh, flaky, and just sweet enough to satisfy your cravings. Their New York-style cheesecake is also worth trying if you’re in the mood for dessert.
Atmosphere and Ambience
Old New York Deli Mammoth combines the feel of a traditional NYC deli with the casual, laid-back vibe of a mountain town café. Inside, you’ll find rustic wooden décor, warm lighting, and an open kitchen that lets you see the action behind the counter. The smell of fresh bagels and brewed coffee fills the space in the morning, offering a comforting start to your day.
Outdoor Seating
During warmer months, guests can enjoy outdoor seating with views of the Village plaza. It’s an excellent spot for people-watching or relaxing after a hike or bike ride. In winter, the interior becomes a cozy refuge from the cold, with plenty of space for families, friends, or solo travelers.
Service and Staff
The staff at Old New York Deli is known for being welcoming and efficient. Even during busy ski weekends or holiday seasons, the team manages to keep things moving without compromising service quality. Whether it’s your first visit or your tenth, the employees make you feel like a valued guest.
Quick, Reliable Service
One of the reasons the deli remains a favorite for many is the quick turnaround time. Even if there’s a line, orders come out promptly and correctly, which is especially appreciated when you’re in a rush to get on the mountain or need a fast breakfast before hitting the road.
Catering and Group Options
Old New York Deli Mammoth also offers catering services for events, meetings, or group gatherings. Whether you’re planning a family reunion or a corporate lunch, the deli can prepare trays of sandwiches, salads, breakfast pastries, and more. This flexibility has made it a go-to option for those planning gatherings in the Mammoth Lakes area.
Vegetarian and Dietary Options
For those with dietary restrictions or preferences, the deli includes a variety of vegetarian-friendly items. From veggie omelets to avocado toast and customizable salads, there are plenty of choices beyond meat-based dishes. While not fully vegan, the menu does offer several adaptable options.
Customer Reviews and Reputation
Online reviews consistently praise the quality of food, the speed of service, and the warm ambiance. Visitors often note how much they appreciate having a reliable, delicious meal available in a town that can get extremely busy during tourist season. Many return year after year, making it a staple part of their Mammoth tradition.
What People Say
- ‘Best bagels in town, hands down!’
- ‘Perfect place for a quick and satisfying breakfast before hitting the slopes.’
- ‘Friendly staff and great food every time we visit.’
Tips for Visiting
If you’re planning to visit Old New York Deli Mammoth, here are a few helpful tips:
- Go early in the morning for the freshest selection of bagels and pastries.
- Expect crowds on weekends and during ski season – arrive early to beat the rush.
- Try something new each time – the menu is large and full of hidden gems.
- Grab a dozen bagels to go if you’re heading out for a long drive or hike.
Old New York Deli Mammoth is more than just a place to grab breakfast or lunch it’s a culinary landmark in the Eastern Sierra. With its roots in New York deli tradition and its heart in the mountain community of Mammoth Lakes, the deli manages to bring together the best of both worlds. Whether you’re in town for a ski trip, summer adventure, or just passing through, a stop at this beloved deli is always worth your time. From freshly baked bagels to hearty sandwiches and warm hospitality, Old New York Deli continues to win over the hearts and appetites of everyone who walks through its doors.