Atty. Demosthenes R. Escoto has played a prominent role in Philippine fisheries administration, particularly during his tenure as National Director of the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR). His leadership period was marked by significant policy developments and legal controversies. From spearheading the implementation of vessel monitoring systems to confronting graft allegations and administrative sanctions, Escoto’s career offers a complex portrait of governance, reform, and accountability in the country’s fisheries sector.
Professional Career and Leadership
Appointment and Oversight Role
On January 18, 2023, Atty. Demosthenes R. Escoto took his oath as Officer-in-Charge and National Director of BFAR, serving under the Department of Agriculture in the Philippines. His appointment signified renewed energy toward regulatory compliance and modernization of fisheries policies in the country
Major Initiatives Under Escoto
During his leadership, Escoto notably pushed for the implementation of a mandatory Vessel Monitoring System (VMS) for commercial fishing vessels. By 2023, some 81¯percent of eligible vessels had installed tracking devices pursuant to Fisheries Administrative Order 266, highlighting his emphasis on transparency and enforcement efficiency
Escoto also supported the public launch of the Fisheries National Administrative Register (FNAR), which records decisions and resolutions relating to fisheries adjudication and contributes to better enforcement and accountability
Legal Challenges and Controversies
Ombudsman Dismissal Order
Despite his reform initiatives, the Office of the Ombudsman issued a dismissal order against Escoto from his position as BFAR National Director. This administrative sanction acknowledged ethical and governance concerns during his tenure
Graft Charges and Trial Proceedings
In February 2025, Escoto was formally arraigned alongside former DA Undersecretary Eduardo B. Gongona on multiple graft charges related to the procurement of a P2¯billion vessel monitoring project awarded to SRT-UK. The charges allege violation of anti-graft laws under Sections 3(e), 3(g), and 3(j) of Republic Act 3019. He pleaded not guilty and posted bail to await trial in court
Advocacy and Policy Impact
Promoting Sustainable Fisheries Enforcement
Environmental groups such as Oceana Philippines publicly commended Escoto’s push for VMS deployment, stressing its role in deterring illegal, unregulated, and unreported fishing. Under his watch, vessel tracking efforts advanced significantly, seen as crucial to protecting artisanal fishermen and preserving marine resources
Advocacy in Legal Cases on Municipal Waters
Escoto represented BFAR in the landmark Supreme Court case G.R. No.¯270929, which sought to uphold the constitutional autonomy of local government units over municipal waters particularly a 15kilometer zone reserved for artisanal fisherfolk. He and the Department of Agriculture challenged decisions perceived as undermining these local rights, demonstrating Escoto’s engagement in broader fisheries governance issues
Public Perception and Legacy
Mixed Leadership Image
Escoto’s tenure is viewed through a dual lens. On one hand, he is praised for championing transparency, digital compliance tools, and fisherfolk legal protections. On the other, he faces serious legal allegations and institutional sanctions that raise questions about decisionmaking and public accountability.
Institutional and Community Reactions
While civil society organizations lauded his VMS initiatives and data transparency efforts, they also urged continuity of reforms despite his dismissal, fearing bureaucratic setbacks. The critical role he played in fisheries code enforcement underscores the institutional void left by his removal
Key Highlights of Escoto’s Impact
- Introduced and achieved high compliance with vessel monitoring systems among commercial fishing fleets.
- Strengthened transparency through implementation of the Fisheries National Administrative Register.
- Advocated for protection of municipal water rights in national courts on behalf of fisherfolk communities.
- Faced administrative dismissal and ongoing court proceedings related to alleged graft in procurement.
Moving Forward: Legal and Institutional Developments
Ongoing Legal Proceedings
As of early 2025, the graft case against Escoto continues through the Regional Trial Court in Cainta, Rizal. The outcome of these charges may significantly affect his public image and potential re-engagement in fisheries governance
Implications for Fisheries Policy
The fate of Escoto’s reforms, especially VMS enforcement and fisheries code implementation, depends on institutional continuity and political will. Civil society pressures highlight the importance of sustaining progress, regardless of personal controversies surrounding former leadership.
Atty. Demosthenes R. Escoto’s tenure at BFAR reflects the complexities of public service in sectors vulnerable to corruption and governance challenges. His efforts toward modernization, transparency, and fisherfolk protection have had a lasting impact on fisheries policy in the Philippines. At the same time, legal proceedings and administrative sanctions cast a shadow over his reform agenda. The unfolding judicial and policy aftermath will shape both his personal legacy and the institutional resilience of fisheries administration in the country.
: