Choosing the perfect paint color can be both exciting and overwhelming, especially when selecting between two popular and closely related shades like Kendall Charcoal and Peppercorn. These dark gray tones are frequently used in modern homes to create depth, contrast, and elegance. Whether you’re painting kitchen cabinets, accent walls, exterior siding, or interior doors, understanding the differences between Kendall Charcoal and Peppercorn will help you make a more confident decision. Both hues bring richness and bold sophistication, but each has unique undertones and characteristics that suit different styles, lighting, and moods.
Understanding the Basics of Kendall Charcoal
What Is Kendall Charcoal?
Kendall Charcoal is a deep gray paint color from Benjamin Moore. It’s known for its balanced tone, sitting comfortably between warm and cool. This makes it highly versatile and a favorite among interior designers for both traditional and contemporary spaces.
Undertones and Appearance
Kendall Charcoal leans slightly warm, with soft brown or greenish undertones depending on the lighting. In bright natural light, it appears more neutral gray. In dim or artificial lighting, the warmth becomes more noticeable. This undertone balance allows it to pair well with creamy whites, muted beiges, and natural wood tones.
Where to Use Kendall Charcoal
This color works beautifully in many areas of the home, such as:
- Exterior trim and shutters
- Accent walls in living rooms or bedrooms
- Kitchen islands and cabinetry
- Office or library spaces
Its refined yet grounded character creates a calming yet sophisticated atmosphere, especially when used with brushed brass or matte black hardware.
Exploring the Features of Peppercorn
What Is Peppercorn?
Peppercorn is a popular dark gray paint color from Sherwin-Williams. It has a sleek, modern appeal and is frequently used for bold accents. Though often categorized as gray, it sometimes borders on charcoal or even near-black depending on the light.
Undertones and Lighting Impact
Peppercorn has cooler undertones compared to Kendall Charcoal. It leans slightly toward blue or purple, especially in rooms with low natural light. In daylight, however, it tends to appear more neutral and crisp. This cooler base makes it an excellent match for cooler whites, blues, and even jewel tones like emerald and navy.
Where to Use Peppercorn
Due to its striking appearance, Peppercorn is ideal for dramatic, modern settings such as:
- Front doors and exterior accents
- Bathroom vanities
- Fireplace walls
- Minimalist interiors
It creates a bold statement and is often chosen for high-contrast design schemes. Metallic finishes like chrome or brushed nickel complement this color well.
Kendall Charcoal vs Peppercorn: Side-by-Side Comparison
Color Depth and Tone
Both colors are dark grays, but Kendall Charcoal has a slightly softer appearance due to its warm undertones. Peppercorn is more intense and has a cooler edge, often reading closer to black in certain lights. This makes Peppercorn bolder and more dramatic, while Kendall Charcoal feels grounded and a bit more adaptable.
Lighting Behavior
Lighting can greatly influence how these shades are perceived. In south-facing rooms with plenty of light, Kendall Charcoal looks elegant and earthy, while Peppercorn appears sleek and modern. In north-facing rooms, Kendall Charcoal may lean warmer, whereas Peppercorn might exhibit cooler blue tones. This lighting response should be a key factor in choosing between them.
Pairing with Other Colors
Each shade matches best with specific palettes:
- Kendall Charcoal: Creamy white (like Benjamin Moore White Dove), taupe, warm beige, olive green, and rich brown.
- Peppercorn: Crisp white (such as Sherwin-Williams Pure White), deep blue, icy gray, blush pink, and silver tones.
Your choice may depend on the surrounding décor and the mood you want to create.
Design Style Compatibility
Kendall Charcoal tends to align with transitional, rustic, and farmhouse styles. It gives a welcoming and cozy vibe while maintaining sophistication. On the other hand, Peppercorn suits modern, industrial, and minimalist aesthetics. Its sharper edge enhances clean lines and high-contrast interiors.
Which One Should You Choose?
Consider Room Function
If you’re painting a room where warmth and comfort are important like a bedroom or family room Kendall Charcoal might be the better fit. For rooms where you want to make a statement, such as a powder room or home office, Peppercorn’s dramatic presence could be more effective.
Think About Light Exposure
Spaces with abundant sunlight can handle the depth of both colors, but dimly lit spaces might benefit more from the subtle warmth of Kendall Charcoal. If you’re going for moody and bold, Peppercorn delivers beautifully in any lighting condition but may make small or dark rooms feel more enclosed.
Test Samples First
The best way to decide is to test both paint colors on your wall. Paint swatches side by side and observe them throughout the day. Notice how they look in the morning, afternoon, and under artificial light in the evening. This real-life comparison helps reveal the undertones and how each color works with your flooring, furniture, and fixtures.
Real-Life Applications and Inspiration
Exteriors and Curb Appeal
Both Kendall Charcoal and Peppercorn are strong choices for home exteriors. Kendall Charcoal works well with stone accents, taupe siding, and natural landscapes. Peppercorn stands out on modern architecture, especially when paired with white trim or black-framed windows.
Cabinetry and Kitchens
Dark gray cabinets are trending, and either color can offer a striking look. Use Kendall Charcoal if you want a slightly softer, traditional feel. Choose Peppercorn if you want ultra-modern, flat-panel cabinets with cool metal hardware.
Accent Walls and Living Spaces
An accent wall in either shade can ground a space and create visual interest. Kendall Charcoal suits rooms with wood accents and cozy textures, while Peppercorn shines with geometric decor and monochromatic styling.
Deciding between Kendall Charcoal vs Peppercorn depends on your space, lighting, design goals, and personal preference. Kendall Charcoal brings a warm, earthy sophistication that’s perfect for traditional or transitional styles. Peppercorn, with its cooler and bolder look, fits modern and edgy interiors. Both are beautiful and timeless choices that can elevate any room when used thoughtfully. Take the time to sample each one in your space to ensure the perfect match for your next design project.